Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 1,083 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • in reply to: Strata Commitee Nomination at AGM #74056
    scotlandx
    Strataguru

      To answer the question – a nomination for election to the Committee can be provided either before the AGM, or at the AGM, provided it is valid. You don’t need to include it in the AGM agenda.

      in reply to: Influencing of votes for an upcoming AGM? #73320
      scotlandx
      Strataguru

        Yes I agree with kaindub. It’s not really a question of whether or not they can present what you believe to be a false case to the other owners (and it may well be). If you are going to the Tribunal and you have a valid case, then you can use what they presented to the owners as part of your case.

        From what you say it sounds like you have grounds for requiring the rectification works, unless I am missing something on the insurance side.

        in reply to: Influencing of votes for an upcoming AGM? #73319
        scotlandx
        Strataguru

          Yes I agree with kaindub. It’s not really a question of whether or not they can present what you believe to be a false case to the other owners (and it may well be). If you are going to the Tribunal and you have a valid case, then you can use what they presented to the owners as part of your case.

          From what you say it sounds like you have grounds for requiring the rectification works, unless I am missing something on the insurance side.

          in reply to: Replacing resigned committee members #73280
          scotlandx
          Strataguru

            Bear in mind that the quorum for any meetings is based on the number set at the AGM, so with 2 people gone your quorum is still 3, i.e. you need all the current members to achieve a quorum.

            in reply to: Long wait for reno approval #73257
            scotlandx
            Strataguru

              Yes you can. If the renovations are straightforward and you have all the information they need, including any by-law etc., it shouldn’t be an issue.

              So ask the Strata Manager if they can do it by written resolution.

               

              in reply to: Unreasonable special levies -WA #73090
              scotlandx
              Strataguru

                Noting I am not familiar with WA strata regulation, but as a general proposition the answer to your question is no.

                If the balconies are defective, then the owners have an obligation to fix them, and that is why they are proposing a special levy. The fact that it may be a burden on one or more owners, unreasonable or otherwise, is not relevant. If you know the balconies are defective then you have to fix them. If you don’t then that can have flow-on consequences for things such as insurance.

                However there may be ways the owners can make it less painful – things you may consider are taking out a strata loan, or structuring the special levy to be paid over time (which it looks like what is proposed), depending on when payment has to be made to the contractors carrying out the work. Or you could borrow the money to pay the levy.

                in reply to: Boundary wall demolition #72796
                scotlandx
                Strataguru

                  I endorse what Jimmy says and also note that the foreman doesn’t have the authority to tell you what the developer wants to do or proposes to do, unless of course he shows you that he has the appropriate delegated authority. I very much doubt that he has that authority.

                  You should tell the foreman if he approaches you again that everything must be in writing, from the party that actually is legally responsible for the development.

                  in reply to: When is an OC meeting not an OC meeting? #72795
                  scotlandx
                  Strataguru

                    Well yes it should be made clear from the start but in this case it doesn’t really matter, because there were no motions and there were no decisions made.

                    However – if they were going to the trouble of convening a “meeting”, then there should at least have been a motion to approve the minutes of the previous meeting. So now at the next meeting you will need a motion for that, and maybe something noting the meeting at which no decisions were made.

                    in reply to: Windows and curtains damaged by fire – who pays? #69322
                    scotlandx
                    Strataguru

                      Thanks andyj!

                      in reply to: RE agent billing for unsold unit costs #69222
                      scotlandx
                      Strataguru

                        Do you have a written and signed contract with the agent? If you do, what does it say?

                        Have you checked that this person has a licence?

                        I am not sure I understand, if you took out two loans, why wouldn’t you be able to pay. Are there are other costs?

                        I tried to post a link to the NSW Fair Trading website about agency agreements but the system thinks it’s spam.

                         

                         

                        in reply to: Windows and curtains damaged by fire – who pays? #69207
                        scotlandx
                        Strataguru

                          I really really want to know what an ANZAC Day display is that involves flames in a bedroom. Clearly my life is very boring.

                          in reply to: Windows and curtains damaged by fire – who pays? #69131
                          scotlandx
                          Strataguru

                            This can be very confusing but the general rule is for strata schemes registered before 1974, doors and windows that fall within a property’s boundary lines are the owner’s responsibility. So you should check the strata plan and the boundary lines for the lots.

                            The curtains and internal repairs are the lot owner’s responsibility and she should claim on her insurance.

                             

                            in reply to: Water ingress and floor boards #68025
                            scotlandx
                            Strataguru

                              This should be covered by the Strata Scheme’s insurance. Tell the strata manager to contact them and progress the claim.

                              There is no 2 year limit.

                              in reply to: Dog left poolside (indoor) while owners out #67563
                              scotlandx
                              Strataguru

                                That poor dog, that is really cruel. Whether or not there is a kennel, being in an area with no shade is dangerous in hot weather. Perhaps these people shouldn’t have a dog.

                                scotlandx
                                Strataguru

                                  You should be allowed to attend and then when the item in which you have an interest is being considered you leave the meeting for that item. That is standard practice. They can’t exclude you from the entire meeting.

                                Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 1,083 total)